Comparison of Google clickthrough rates by position [#ChartoftheDay]

Clickthrough research data reveals the importance of 1st, 2nd or 3rd position in Google

You often hear company owners saying “I want to rank top” for their target keywords. Although this may be an unrealistic hope, they’re right to say this since they realise that the proportion of clicks driven by top positions is much higher.

Research showing average clickthrough rates by position in the SERPs (Google's search results pages) are useful since they can help make the business case for more investment in SEO since you can estimate uplift in visits with improved rankings when performing a gap analysis for which keywords to improve in SEO, using search query data from Google Search console, for example.

The best open source for this data today is the Advanced Web Ranking organic CTR research which we share here, so you can check out the different CTR analysis it gives. This data is from July 2016 - the most recent update of the research. We will look at 3 examples of how CTR varies by position depending on different searcher intent.

 1. Organic SERPs CTRs for Brand vs non-branded keyword intent

It's well known that clickthrough rates for branded or navigational keywords are higher - the blue curve shows this well.

The red curve is of most interest from an SEO point-of-view. This shows the value of being in the top 3 clearly with CTRs from 30% in first position to 12% in third position. In the lower positions of 9 to 10, CTR has fallen to a paltry sub 2%.

branded-vs-unbranded-ctr-by-position

Here branded CTRs are selected by AWR when part of the string in the domain name appears in the search.

 2. Organic SERPs CTRs for generic vs long-tail terms

Generic searches for products are typically 1 or 2 words. Long tail terms are 4 or more. This chart shows a  similar pattern of decline to above, but a higher level of CTR for the long-tail SEO technique by 3 to 5% by position. Typically this will because long-tail searches have fewer ads and competition may be lower. It shows the benefit of an approach targeting long-tail keywords.

Google organic seoclickthrough rate by position in serps

3. Organic SERPs CTRs variation based on intent type

We see a similar decline here, but with lowest figures for commerical and location-based intent where there is typically more competition from AdWords clicks and other SERPS features such as maps for location searches.
ctr-by-intent-type-for-seo-2016

Here the different search intent types are defined by these keywords in the search query :

  • Commercial intent -  buy, purchase, cheap, pricing, etc.
  • Informational intent - what, when, where, how, restaurant, hotel, flight, news, etc.
  • Location intent - near, nearby, from, directions, airport, route, maps, etc.
  • Specific intent - sums up the keywords with all three intents described above.

Previous research on organic CTR by position in SERPS

This post updates on previous research, summarised by Chris Soames, an analysis of natural search clickthrough rates (CTRs) from Optify showed the importance of Page 1 and, in particular the top 3 positions. The AWR data has the advantage that is updated regularly based on reports across their clients, so samples thousands of sites. It also has some category breakdown and also takes screen resolution for smartphone into account.

Optify Clickthrough rate ranking data

Chris also showed how you can use this curve to model the search volume you will get for different positions - this can be used to make the case for more investment in SEO.

The Optify data wasn’t across all industries and also limited in that it didn’t isolate the impact of brand terms (which account for a high proportion of search and tend to have a higher percentage of clicks on the top position).

Given these limitations of the Optify data, it was good to see a cross-industry comparison of CTRs published by MEC Manchester. Their infographic showing Google clickthrough rates by position certainly makes for interesting reading.

Brand vs non-brand clickthrough rates

You can clearly see the higher clickthrough rates for brand terms here and how they impact the overall rates.

Sector-specific clickthrough rates

The industry reports are interesting too - showing a surprising amount of variation between sectors, but there is a common pattern of the first three positions accounting for over 50% of clicks...

Paid vs natural share of search clicks

Another insight in this research shows that despite Google’s changes to the SERPs over the years, which have been roundly derided by SEOs, the vast majority of clicks are still on the natural listings. This research suggests 94% on the natural listings. A much higher proportion than previous data from the likes of iProspect from several years ago.

Methodology

Although published in Summer 2012, this research dates back to June 2011, so doesn’t reflect the latest changes to the SERPs results. The research is based on 28 million people in the UK, making a total 1.4 billion search queries during June 2011. It’s based on research from GroupM UK carried out with Nielsen.

Here is the full infographic.



Share your thoughts

  • Guest commented on January 10, 2014

    The brand vs. non-brand breakdown, as well as the breakdown-by-industry, was insightful. I have wondered how people might approach a search for, say, a roofer, differently than they would for finding an answer to an informational question. Also, I wonder how local listings play into all of this. My site, http://www.RoofRinseRun.com, has listings in both currently, and I wonder if the local section drives more of the traffic…

  • Luke Kellett commented on December 17, 2013

    Hi Dave,
    Enjoyed this article but just realised that the data was taken from June 2011, things seem to have come along way since then, do you know of any more recent data written in a similar fashion?

  • The PPC vs. natural stat can’t be right. Just the aggregate on the clients we manage where the average paid position is around 2ish, our CTR is about 3.45%. So many campaigns have really high CTR averaging about 6%. Are we just that good?? 😉

  • SemMetric commented on October 2, 2012

    It would have been interesting to see the verticals CTRs segmented by branded and non-branded terms.

  • Is this all based off of users in the UK?

    • Hi Eric,

      Yes, as it says in the Methodology section:

      “The research is based on 28 million people in the UK, making a total 1.4 billion search queries during June 2011”.

      Where were you looking for data from?

  • The paid search vs organic CTR figure is interesting. As you mentioned, iProspect (and Hubspot) had previously reported a significantly higher figure in favour of PPC clicks. I would certainly be keen to see more research in this area to see if there’s any fluctuation in the data.

    • Yes Jonathan, my first thought was “I don’t believe this” given Google has made paid search dominate.

      However, the data will naturally include search terms which have no/few AdWords, so this will bring the figure down. Not sure what that % of queries for which ads aren’t presented is though – you need that data for context.

  • Great stats, really interesting. Will be ramping up the PPC budget if i ever need to target the 60yo Female segment!
    Anyone have any idea what average PPC CTR’s are in relation to ad positions?

    • Hi Tom,

      Good question, but I don’t think any similar research has been published recently.
      The PPC CTR figures I used to use in my books were from year’s back from Atlas – see http://www.seobook.com/archives/000422.shtml.
      Of course Google Analytics has a good way of seeing your own CTR for position in AdWords, but haven’t seen benchmark info.
      Good luck with the 60 YO Female targeting!

      Dave

Get FREE marketing planning templates

Start your Digital Marketing Plan today with our free Basic membership.

  • FREE fast start guides to review your approach
  • FREE digital marketing plan templates
  • FREE alerts on the latest developments

Need help with your Search Engine Optimisation (SEO)?

Get more from your digital marketing with in-company or remote training and consultancy from Smart Insights

Get FREE marketing planning templates

Start your Digital Marketing Plan today with our free Basic membership.

  • FREE fast start guides to review your approach
  • FREE digital marketing plan templates
  • FREE alerts on the latest developments