Digital Transformation - Shaping Your Digital Future
We can help you on your journey to successFind out More
Save 50% on Annual
Membership in August
This headline from Business Insider has to be the most misleading of the year for me. It’s certainly engaging, but what's it based upon? When Andy Lloyd Gordon shared it through Twitter yesterday I couldn’t resist clicking to see what this claim was based on.
The report by Sucharita Mulpuru, an analyst at Forrester Research showed that less than 1 percent of the online transactions amongst US customers could be traced to a social media post.
The article states:
"Social tactics are not meaningful sales drivers.
While the hype around social networks as a driver of influence in eCommerce continues to capture the attention of online executives, the truth is that social continues to struggle and registers as a barely negligible source of sales for either new or repeat buyers.
In fact, fewer than 1% of transactions for both new and repeat shoppers could be traced back to trackable social links."
Retail transactions from 2012 included single touchpoint transactions and multiple touchpoint attribution. For new customers acquisition, 67% of which involved a single touchpoint, 20% were direct visits, 16% were organic search and 11% were paid search. Social media were less than 1% for both single touchpoint and multiple touchpoint attribution analysis.
So what is this based on and who does it refer to? Well it isn’t a survey of retailer or consumer perceptions. Business Insider didn’t go into the methodology, that might get in the way of the headline, but it’s based on primary web analytics data of transactions from US customers of retail clients of GSI Ecommerce.
The clients of GSI are well-known retail brands particularly in clothing, e.g. DKNY, Levis and Speedo and toys (ToysRus), Early Learning Centre and Mattel.
So, it’s a credible source, indeed we featured data from the same survey a year ago when discussing the importance of Email marketing to retail sales - that’s the angle we took…
Business Insider noted:
“Mulpuru didn’t study small businesses, which she said do disproportionately well in social commerce”.
Despite this, even for big brands we might expect to see more direct influence of social on sales since this is not a “last click” study, the research does look at multiple touchpoints although the cookie window for attribution isn’t reviewed, we can assume it’s 30 days?
So what can we learn from this given that this is a credible study? Well it’s certainly a reminder of the power of other digital channels in driving sales. Paid and Organic, email marketing (from existing customers) and to a lesser extent display advertising and comparison sites are undeniably still key sales drivers so they merit investment and work on improving their efficiency through following best practices.
I still think that the conclusion that Facebook and Twitter Do almost nothing to drive sales is still highly misleading, since a direct response view of effectiveness. For me, investment in engagement through social media is still warranted since this study doesn’t look at what develops brand awareness and brand preference at the top of the conversion funnel.
It’s also worth remembering the difficulties of tracking social media effectiveness. Indeed many of the visits from direct site visits (the top referrer at 20%) and brand search terms may have been influenced by social media engagement. Then there's the role of social media in influencing offline sales.
There are also technical reasons why social media may be undercounted including:
What do you think? Do you think this report suggests we may be paying too much attention and focusing too much resource on social media or do you think the report is misleading?
By Dave Chaffey
Dave is CEO and co-founder of Smart Insights. He is editor of the 100 templates, ebooks and courses in the digital marketing resource library created by our team of 25+ Digital Marketing experts. Our resources used by our Expert members in more than 80 countries to Map, Plan and Manage their digital marketing. For my full profile, or to connect on LinkedIn or other social networks, see the About Dave Chaffey profile page on Smart Insights. Dave is author of 5 bestselling books on digital marketing including Emarketing Excellence and Digital Marketing: Strategy, Implementation and Practice. In 2004 he was recognised by the Chartered Institute of Marketing as one of 50 marketing ‘gurus’ worldwide who have helped shape the future of marketing.
Start the discussion on our community and social networks
Recommended Blog Posts
Social Media Essentials: Catch up with the latest updates in social media Spotlight story: Facebook launches Crisis Response hub This year we have seen a number of disasters globally from the Manchester attacks to hurricane Harvey. In response, Facebook has been developing ways …..
Facebook launches one of its most impactful tools, making it a place where users can connect for help in the midst of crisis This year we have seen a number of disasters globally from the Manchester attacks to hurricane Harvey. In response, Facebook …..
Popular Blog Posts
Statistics on consumer mobile usage and adoption to inform your mobile marketing strategy mobile site design and app development “Mobile to overtake fixed Internet access by 2014” was the huge headline summarising the bold prediction from 2008 by Mary Meeker, an …..
Landing page examples and best practice advice Discussion of web design in companies who don’t know the power of landing pages still often focuses on the home page. But savvy companies know that custom landing pages are essential to maximise conversion …..
Use the RACE Planning System to get ahead in your digital marketing The first edition of my book Internet Marketing: Strategy, Planning and Implementation from 2001 included a popular template for creating what we then called an Internet Marketing Plan. Today, …..